TV Review: Muhammad Alis Greatest Fight

 Posted on August 25, 2024  |  6 minutes  |  1104 words  |  Reinaldo Massengill

HBO's historical movie chronicles fascinating story in a mundane way

The subject matter is so intriguing as to exacerbate the sense that “Muhammad Ali’s Greatest Fight” is something of a letdown, dramatically speaking. Anchored by Frank Langella and Christopher Plummer’s performances as Supreme Court Justices Warren Berger and John Harlan, this Vietnam-era story focuses on the court battle over Ali’s conscientious-objector status as a devout Muslim, which derailed the champ’s boxing career. Filled with interesting tidbits, director Stephen Frears’ film never quite coalesces — floating like a butterfly, all right, but delivering so little sting as to barely leave a mark.

Ali himself is presented only in archival newsreel footage and interviews, while the nine justices hash out what to do about his conviction and appeal. Cast to the hilt, in addition to Langella (who has now played both Richard Nixon and his Chief Justice) as the avuncular, patrician Berger, with Plummer as the wily, ailing Harlan, there’s Fritz Weaver (Hugo Black), Harris Yulin (William O. Douglas), Peter Gerety (William Brennan Jr.), director Barry Levinson (Potter Stewart), John Bedford Lloyd (Byron “Whizzer” White), Ed Begley Jr. (Harry Blackmun) and a blink-and-you’ll-miss-him Danny Glover (Thurgood Marshall, who recused himself from the case).

Related Stories

A wrecking ball swinging towards an old TV with a TV host on the screen VIP+

Late-Night TV vs. YouTube: Data-Driven Tips on Which Is Better for Celebs Promoting Films

Secret Level

'Secret Level' Director Tim Miller and Epic Games Execs Talk Hollywood's Relationship With Unreal Engine as Version 5.5 Launches

The entry point, however, is less about the justices than one of Harlan’s clerks, Kevin Connolly (“Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter’s” Benjamin Walker), who butts heads with the snooty Ivy Leaguers, forges a close bond with his boss, and also attempts to steer Harlan’s reasoning toward Ali’s side. (For a second take, by the way, see Leslie Felperin’s review when the movie screened at Cannes.)

Popular on Variety

That portion of the film, alas, as written by Shawn Slovo, is stilted and flat, leaving not enough time with the justices, who — in the made-for’s most amusing moment — regularly retire downstairs to watch X-rated movies in order to decide on pornography cases. (It was Stewart who famously said, “I know it when I see it.”)

Despite the allure of getting a bird’s-eye-view at the often puzzling and arcane machinations of the Supreme Court — during one of the most tumultuous periods in the country’s history, no less — the movie will be most interesting for those who can parse what amount to its asides, like the fact Blackmun (who would ultimately write the Roe v. Wade decision) is perceived as being constantly aligned with the conservative Berger, who freely acknowledges his awareness of politics and friendship with Nixon in steering court decisions.

Admittedly, it’s hard not to root for a movie audacious enough to prominently feature so many actors in their 70s and 80s, including the 83-year-old Plummer, who isn’t even the oldest among the principal players. (That distinction belongs to fellow octogenarian Weaver as Black, a legendary jurist who remained on the court until eight days before his death at the age of 85.)

Nevertheless, if Frears’ earnest interpretation isn’t quite a missed opportunity, it’s an under-realized one. Yes, it’s worth watching for the historical moment it represents — particularly since that moment continues to echo through to the present — but it’s less compelling than it might have been.

Not that I can fully explain what would have made “Muhammad Ali’s Greatest Fight” more satisfying. But I’d know it when I see it.

Read More About:

Jump to Comments

TV Review: ‘Muhammad Ali’s Greatest Fight’

(Movie; HBO, Sat. Oct. 5, 8 p.m.)

  • Production: Filmed in New York by Rainmark Films in association with Sakura Films.
  • Crew: Executive producers, Tracey Scoffield, Frank Doelger, Jonathan Cameron; producer, Scott Ferguson; director, Stephen Frears; writer, Shawn Slovo, based on the book by Howard L. Bingham, Max Wallace; camera, Jim Denault; production designer, Dan Davis; editor, Mick Audsley; music, George Fenton; casting, Kathleen Chopin, Victoria Thomas. 98 MIN.
  • Cast: Christopher Plummer, Frank Langella, Benjamin Walker, Peter Gerety, Barry Levinson, Fritz Weaver, John Bedford Lloyd, Danny Glover, Ed Begley Jr., Harris Yulin, Pablo Schreiber

More from Variety

Most Popular

Must Read

Sign Up for Variety Newsletters

By providing your information, you agree to our Terms of Use and our Privacy Policy.We use vendors that may also process your information to help provide our services. // This site is protected by reCAPTCHA Enterprise and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Variety Confidential

A Variety and iHeartRadio Podcast

ncG1vNJzZmiukae2psDYZ5qopV9nfXJ%2Fjq2taKqVq7amw9Joq69loprDqrHWZqSuoJGiuqKwjJqjoqtdnL%2BmrdOeqq1llp60qcCMamlpaGZtf3d%2Bj2g%3D